Dr. Julie Harrigan, hospitalist and founder of Physician EHR Solutions, joins Mindbowser CEO Ayush Jain to explain what it takes to standardize how a multi-hospital system practices medicine. She came into clinical informatics by accident: after complaining about a new EHR, and bringing solutions with every complaint, she was hired as a consultant, went on to become chief medical informatics officer at Ardent Health Services, and helped take a 30-hospital system onto one standardized record. Her proof point is COVID: because order sets and workflows were identical, clinicians from New Mexico and Idaho could fly to overwhelmed New Jersey hospitals, badge in and start working. She names the obstacles to rolling out an EHR like Epic across a system: shrinking capital budgets squeezed by denials, and physicians who won’t use guidelines they had no hand in. On AI, she welcomes predictive analytics for conditions like sepsis and help with note writing, but wants clinicians to treat it “not as a crutch but a great suggestive help.” She closes with the purpose behind her work: helping hospitals that want consistent, evidence-based care but don’t know where to start.
Julie didn’t plan on clinical informatics. Shortly after she finished residency and started as a hospitalist, her hospital implemented a new EHR. She understood programming intuitively, saw “the good, the bad and the ugly and how to fix it,” and started complaining, always with a viable fix attached. The IT team, she jokes, got tired of hearing from her and hired her as a consultant. She went on to help Ardent Health Services implement its first 12 standardized EHRs in New Mexico and Oklahoma, became its chief medical informatics officer, and saw all 30 hospitals go live on one standardized system. Since then her firm has worked on EHR standardization at RWJBarnabas Health in New Jersey and on consolidating the EHR at Corewell Health, which she describes as 22 hospitals and more than 5,500 beds.
Her favorite example comes from COVID. After three and a half years of putting Ardent’s hospitals on Epic and standardizing everything down to policies and provider order sets, New Jersey hospitals were overwhelmed while hospitals in Albuquerque and Idaho were not yet. Physicians and nurses flew east, took a tour, got their badges and started working immediately, because the systems and workflows were identical. She argues that reducing variability in practice doesn’t kill the art of medicine: it lowers provider burden, reduces cost variability, can improve reimbursement, and builds the kind of high reliability organization where doing it right once means doing it right every time.
Asked what stops health systems embracing technology, Julie starts with cost. Systems are moving toward large consolidated EHRs rather than homegrown ones, but reimbursement pressure and payer denials after COVID have squeezed the capital and operational budgets they’d use to buy third-party tools on top of that base system. The second obstacle is end users. Documentation requirements load so much busywork onto physicians that they push back. Her fixes: reduce unnecessary testing and practice variability, use point-of-care documentation tools that make stays harder for payers to deny, and bring physician subject matter experts into the change itself, because “word of mouth is better than any commercial you could ever present.”
Julie is enthusiastic about predictive analytics for early detection of sepsis, coronary disease and lung cancer, about algorithmic guidance for treatment, and about AI that helps with note writing and consolidation. Her caution is about adoption: health systems need to educate clinicians to keep making their own decisions and use AI “not as a crutch but a great suggestive help.” That is the same tension teams hit when designing AI for clinical documentation and decision support, where clinician trust has to be earned. Dr. Michal Tzuchman Katz of Kahun made a related case on the show for AI that supports physicians’ clinical reasoning rather than replacing it.
Physicians see a patient for five or ten minutes, then spend 30 minutes at the computer on the same chart. Julie wants technology at their fingertips instead of a hunt for a free computer and a printer, and she’d like to dictate a note while walking down the hallway and trust it to complete. She also wants the industry to push back on payers, including the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, whose “silver platter” documentation demands are taught nowhere in medical school or residency. Her own career story, from foreign medical graduate to physician executive, is in her DEI series episode.
Hello, beautiful people. In today’s podcast we’re going to host Julie Harrigan, CEO and founder of Physician EHR Solutions. Physician EHR Solutions is an advisory service for hospitals, healthcare systems and outpatient practices that specializes in provider workflow, clinical improvements and electronic health record (EHR) implementation. In this podcast we are going to touch upon technology for making life easy for physicians, integrating it with workflows, and how AI can change the landscape of the technology proposition. Hello Julie, how are you today?
Hi Ayush, I’m doing well. Thank you very much for having me.
I’m so glad we are having this podcast, because your background is so unique: from a physician to someone who is helping other physicians be empowered with more technology and information. So why don’t you do a quick introduction about yourself, Julie, where it all started, and then talk more about the present day. What does your company do?
Absolutely. So, Julie Harrigan. I’m an experienced hospitalist. I got into medicine out of prep school back in 1997, did my medical school in Mexico at the [inaudible], and from there did a year and a half of residency and came to the United States thereafter. One of the purposes of coming to the United States was to practice more evidence-based medicine, and that launched my career into, oddly enough, clinical informatics, which was not something I had planned on initially.
My second residency was in family medicine at UNM, the University of New Mexico, in Albuquerque, New Mexico, where I live currently. I became a hospitalist in 2009, only because I didn’t want to be on call anymore, and clinic didn’t seem like a great option as far as outpatient practice, and I’ve practiced as a full-time hospitalist really ever since.
I came into the clinical informatics world just by happenstance. We had implemented a new electronic health record very shortly after I got out of residency and started working as a hospitalist, and I understood a lot about programming just intuitively. It’s always come very naturally to me. I really understood the good, the bad and the ugly, and how to fix it. So, being the opinionated person that I am, I immediately started complaining, but then providing viable solutions to our healthcare IT crew at that time. Very shortly after, and I’m pretty sure they were tired of me complaining incessantly, they hired me on as a consultant.
I thereafter proceeded to help the hospital system, which is Ardent Health Services, now a 30-hospital company, implement their first 12 standardized electronic health records in New Mexico and Oklahoma. From there I was hired as their chief medical informatics officer, implementing and standardizing a 30-hospital system, and we went live with all 30 hospitals and really standardized care throughout that hospital system.
When I departed from them, a little over five years later, I started my own LLC, Physician EHR Solutions, and was immediately hired to help implement an electronic health record system and standardize the system for RWJBarnabas Health in New Jersey, so a multi-hospital system. And now I’ve moved on to Corewell Health, which is again a large hospital system, 22 hospitals and over 5,500 beds, to consolidate their EHR and then standardize their system as well, with regard to policies, physician workflows, practice standardization, regulatory and all of that. So it’s been quite a journey over the last 14 years that I’ve been in clinical informatics, and I’ve very much enjoyed it.
Great, super awesome. I think that has been a journey of great determination, and of welcoming any new opportunities that came your way, and that’s something anybody who’s building a career should be learning: you should be open to anything that comes. So tell us more specifically about your day-to-day work, because I understand that Physician EHR Solutions is more of a consulting company now, helping different hospitals and healthcare systems in their workflow management and clinical improvement. Go deeper into it: how does this whole consulting work, and what kind of results have you been able to drive? Especially if you can explain with an example, that would be great.
Absolutely. I primarily work in the executive C-suite space, so I work directly with chief medical officers (CMOs) and chief operating officers to ensure that everything that goes into their electronic health record implementation is also operationally viable, cost-effective, consensus-driven and very much evidence-based. There are national and international standards of care that every hospital system really should adhere to. We don’t want to kill the art of medicine, but reducing variability in practice not only reduces provider burden, it can bolster educational and academic centers, decrease cost variability and improve reimbursement from payers, if you do it in the correct manner. So on a daily basis I’m riddled with meetings, anything from policy meetings to operational meetings to budgetary meetings, to see how we can more cost-effectively implement these things and then translate them into day-to-day clinical practice, for the improvement of care for our patients and to reduce provider and clinician burden.
One of my favorite examples of how healthcare standardization can be very effective in a healthcare system was during COVID. I was the chief medical information officer (CMIO) for Ardent. We had 30 hospitals, and over the previous three and a half years we had been working on implementing our electronic health record, which is Epic, and then standardizing those practices, down to policies for each hospital, into one organized fashion under the Ardent umbrella.
What it resulted in was great collaboration between the hospitals. We had hospitals in New Jersey that were absolutely overwhelmed with COVID patients, just as New York was, and we had hospitals in Albuquerque, New Mexico, and in Ohio, or Idaho rather, I’m sorry, that were not as burdened, at least at that time, when everything was exploding on the East Coast. We were able to take providers and nurses and send them to those hospitals in New Jersey, and all they had to do was take a tour of the hospital and get their badges, and they were able to immediately badge into their computers and start working, because everything was standardized. We had a unified way of working, all the way down to things like provider order sets, to help with patient care. So it really made it a no-brainer for those providers to cross state lines, go all the way across the United States and pick up where they left off, just with a different subset of patients.
It really goes to show how consolidating those practices and having the best evidence-based and consensus-based practice can reduce that variability of practice, improve cost-effectiveness and really increase efficiency across the board.
No, fantastic, actually, because I believe processes definitely help. I’ve always believed that. In fact, there was the Japan Airlines evacuation a couple of weeks back, if you noticed that news. Just because of the good training and the processes that were in place, they were able to evacuate close to 375 passengers unharmed within 18 minutes, with half of the aeroplane already engulfed in fire. People call it a lucky thing, but it was all due to the workflows, the processes and the training that were already in place. So it was a really good case study of how getting those foundations strong can lead to better results, especially in the critical scheme of things.
Absolutely. And it contributes to that high reliability organization, right? Do it right the first time and you get it right, and you’re going to do it right the second and third time.
Exactly, to your point. So I have a counter question. In your practice, since you’re dealing with the stakeholders all the time, and like we discussed, this is so useful and critical, what are the biggest obstacles in embracing such a change, especially when it comes to technology? You could talk about the technology viewpoint, but also overall workflows and business processes. What have been the biggest obstacles, and what would be your advice to health systems?
I think some of the biggest obstacles to embracing technology in healthcare systems are certainly cost, and the decisions that are made. I think we’re moving toward a culture of more consolidated, large electronic health record systems, as opposed to all these multiple mom-and-pop and homegrown systems, but cost certainly factors into that. One of the hurdles to being able to embrace technology, and then decide what third-party technologies you integrate into your base system thereafter, is that, and COVID was a pivotal time in healthcare, especially in the United States, healthcare systems are struggling with things like reimbursements. They’re struggling with things like denials from payer organizations, because they’re having to jump through many, many hoops, and that reduces their capital budget and operational budget to be able to purchase these technologies. So I think that’s definitely one huge hurdle.
The other, honestly, is the lack of end-user feedback and end-user utilization of the electronic health records. There’s so much burden in documentation requirements at this time. I don’t understand how it is in Europe and in other countries as much, but knowing how it is in the United States, there’s so much burden placed on the clinician, on the physician (and I’m sorry about my dogs) to have this documentation and present it to payers on a silver platter, and also take care of their patients in the meantime. There’s so much busywork going on that you get a lot of pushback from your providers.
A couple of things come to mind as solutions for hospitals and healthcare systems to get rid of those obstacles, or at least move them aside or reduce them. One is if we could reduce some of that variability in practice and decrease costs of care, not ordering unnecessary testing and things like that, which certainly improves hospital reimbursement and decreases the cost of care. Utilizing some third-party systems as well to decrease denial rates, things like point-of-care documentation for physicians, so that healthcare companies can’t come back and deny patient stays based on their patient class and such, which is a huge reimbursement factor for hospitals, and obviously improves both their operational budget and their capital budget.
And increasing physician buy-in. Consensus is a great thing in medicine. You have your evidence-based practice, you can have all the guidelines you want, but if you present those to the physician, at the end of the day they still aren’t going to want to use them if they have their own opinions about how to practice. So take those subject matter experts and involve them in the process of making those changes within your healthcare organization. You’ll increase the buy-in. Word of mouth is better than any commercial you could ever present to them, and it really increases the utilization of the electronic health record and helps to bolster its utilization.
Rightly said.
This episode of the HealthTech with Purpose podcast is brought to you by Mindbowser, a product engineering and digital transformation company focused on health. At Mindbowser, we enable health companies to build the future of health with accessible, equitable [inaudible] patient care. We strongly believe that technology can empower a healthier world, and that’s why we are partnering with healthcare experts like you to make it happen.
Hi guys, thanks for listening to HealthTech with Purpose. Make sure to subscribe to us on Spotify, Apple and YouTube for more expert insights on industry innovation and transformation. And remember: share the knowledge.
So Julie, there has been a lot of talk about AI. In fact, last year pretty much went all into AI. I was at a few conferences last year, and I could see every company: AI for X, AI for Y, AI for Z. You would be a great person to answer this question: what is the reality currently on the ground? Since you see both worlds, from the technology viewpoint as well as the health viewpoint, how much has the reality changed, first in the present day, and second, what do you think about the future?
There’s so much swirling in the world of artificial intelligence at this point. I’ve been listening to podcasts and watching debates from the giants of the AI world, and really the creators of the AI world, debating the good, the bad and the ugly of AI. Are we going to end up in the Terminator world, where robots are ruling our lives and we’re slaves to them, and this is going to be the ultimate end of humanity? I think that’s certainly debatable, but an interesting subject nonetheless.
AI is really changing the landscape of a great many things, not really limited to healthcare but in all facets of our lives at this point. ChatGPT revolutionized even essay writing in schools, so it’s gotten very interesting. I think our biggest issue with AI, and not really an issue, but something we need to be conscientious about as healthcare systems, is how we adopt AI, how it’s utilized, and making sure it’s not taking the subjectivity and the art of medicine out of our hospitals.
Predictive analytics, for example, is a great example of how we can really utilize this to bolster our efforts in detecting things like early sepsis and coronary diseases and lung cancers and such. But we still need that touch and feel of human-to-human contact, which is very necessary for making those clinical decisions. So adoption of AI for things like bolstering our electronic health records, some of that predictive analytics, and then utilizing AI to help make those decisions or guide clinicians on how they should treat patients in an algorithmic fashion, and things like simple note-writing techniques and consolidation, can be very useful for the average clinician, and even going above and beyond that.
But again, we have to be very conscientious of how we’re utilizing it. In the world we live in, it’s so easy for something to make decisions for us, and we need to make sure we’re educating our hospitals, our healthcare systems and, moreover, our clinicians to maintain that objectivity, maintain that subjectivity, make sure they’re still making decisions for themselves, and utilize artificial intelligence not as a crutch but as a great suggestive help.
Well said. And I think in the non-clinical things AI is already doing a good job, but it will be all about how we see the advent of AI in clinical roles: basically a perfect companion, the right companion, for doctors and physicians. Which brings me to the point you have always been advocating in your past work. I’ve always seen you talk about physician burden, how we can make it lesser, the burnout for physicians. Do you think AI could be that solution, and what can we do about it?
Yeah, absolutely. Most of the time spent by physicians at this point is at the computer. You see your patients for five or 10 minutes, you talk to their families, you go back to the computer and you work for 30 minutes on the same chart you were just looking at.
So a few things I think can reduce provider burden. We need to empower physicians with more tech and make it much more palatable to them. Things like having it at your fingertips. I mean, here’s my phone. There are a few healthcare EHR companies who are really empowering providers to utilize that technology at their fingertips and provide care for their patients on the fly, so that you’re not sitting down in front of a desk, fighting for a computer, looking for a printer, doing all of that stuff, which takes chunks of minutes out of your day, but cumulatively it’s really hours. And that’s really contributing to a lot of provider burnout.
One of the things we can do, again especially here in the United States, is push back on payers and the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) and all of those institutions that really require this silver-platter, perfect, bullet-pointed documentation on patients in the patient’s electronic health record. It’s burdening physicians. They’re not teaching these things in medical school. They’re not teaching them in residency. They’re teaching you to care for your patient, to do the right thing, to do no harm, to treat them appropriately, to maintain standards of care. But they’re really not teaching to documentation requirements just to satisfy what the payer documenters want, who are non-physicians, mind you. They’re clinicians at best, they might be nurses, but still, they’re not living in the physician’s mind. So decreasing the burden of some of that documentation would be very, very helpful.
I think also shift times. Not necessarily in the tech world, but reducing the length of time one needs to spend rounding in the hospital can reduce some of that burden, because at the end of the day, 12 hours is a really long day, even if you get a few days off.
And then again, from a technology standpoint, putting it more at their fingertips, making it more accessible. If I could take my note and dictate it while I’m walking down the hallway, or driving in my car, doing other things, and not being distracted necessarily, but understanding that it will still complete that process very seamlessly. I think we can encourage electronic health record companies and other third-party vendors to help with solutions for that, and incorporate AI into that realm as well, to really help with those workflows.
Well said, well said. It makes so much sense, and I hope AI can really solve this problem, because it really harms providers, and if they can invest their time in what makes them the best, I think that helps everybody.
Absolutely.
Yeah. So Julie, closing notes. Since this is the HealthTech with Purpose podcast, we always like to know about your purpose in doing what you are doing. Would you like to share a bit on the personal side: what drives you, and what has been your purpose in life?
Thank you. I think what really drives me is this: I’ve been a patient in the hospital, my parents have been patients in the hospital, my children have been patients in the hospital, and most recently my husband was a patient in the hospital. And I’ve seen healthcare go from paper, with these huge binders that used to be so cumbersome, picking up charts outside the door of the patient’s room, to now being completely electronic. I’ve gone through that in my personal life and in my professional life and seen the evolution of it.
And I’ve really seen how much variability there is in how we practice medicine, from hospital to hospital, from physician to physician, from company to company, healthcare system to healthcare system, nationally and internationally. What drives me is the basic fundamentals of improving healthcare. It’s not enough that there’s some consensus-driven medicine in some healthcare systems. You have places like Mayo Clinic and Cleveland Clinic that seem to have a lot of their act together, but then you have other hospital systems that want to do that but don’t really know how to start, and don’t really know where even the pivot point is.
So my driving purpose is to help those organizations that need that pivotal organizational, motivational help: help them organize how they practice without compromising the art of medicine, certainly, because patients are variable and healthcare is variable, but help them do the right thing as much as absolutely possible. Improve patient care, improve the provider experience, reduce the cost of care and practice medicine more efficiently, because we’re getting older and sicker, there are more patients, and it’s a mess. If we can improve how we practice, ultimately the system will work as intended. I think that’s really the driving force of what I do in healthcare information technology: to help bolster those efforts in coordination with our leadership and organizations.
Yeah, and I hope we’ll get there, bit by bit, every day.
So I’m whittling away.
Thank you so much, everybody. This was Julie Harrigan, MD, CEO and founder of Physician EHR Solutions. Thank you so much, Julie, for joining us today.
Thank you very much for having me.
At the time of recording (published February 2024), Dr. Julie Harrigan was a hospitalist and the CEO and founder of Physician EHR Solutions, an advisory service for hospitals, healthcare systems and outpatient practices specializing in provider workflow, clinical improvement and EHR implementation. She attended medical school in Mexico, completed a family medicine residency at the University of New Mexico in Albuquerque, and had practiced as a hospitalist since 2009. She described 14 years in clinical informatics, including serving as chief medical informatics officer at Ardent Health Services during its move to a standardized Epic record, EHR standardization work for RWJBarnabas Health in New Jersey, and EHR consolidation at Corewell Health. She was named CMIO of the Year at the Forttuna Global Excellence Awards 2024.
Rolling out a new EHR or AI tool and worried physicians won’t use it? Tell us about the workflow and we’ll show you how we’d build around it.
Partner with us to design, build, and scale digital solutions that drive better outcomes.
Global Tech Teams LLC, 525 Washington Blvd, Industrious at Newport Tower, Jersey City, NJ 07310, United States.
Let’s discuss your goals, workflows, and next steps in a focused consultation call.