Let’s dive into the world of software development and explore the fascinating topic of singletons. This discussion is all about shedding light on the role of singletons in Dart/Flutter development. We’ll be delving into the different perspectives and lively debates surrounding this hot topic. So, whether you’re a developer who believes in their value or someone who thinks they should be avoided, this is the perfect opportunity to gain a deeper understanding. Let’s explore together!
By the end of this exploration, you’ll understand why singletons can make code less maintainable and testable and learn about alternative strategies to consider.
A singleton is a design pattern that restricts the instantiation of a class to a single instance and provides a global point of access to it. According to Wikipedia, the singleton pattern:
In essence, a singleton pattern guarantees that only one instance of a class is created, making it accessible globally. This is particularly useful for managing shared resources or coordinating certain actions across an application.
Here’s a straightforward implementation of a singleton in Dart:
```dart
class Singleton {
Singleton._(); // private constructor
static final instance = Singleton._(); // single instance
}By making the constructor private, you ensure that the class cannot be instantiated outside the file where it is defined. Consequently, the only way to access the singleton is through `Singleton.instance`. In some cases, a static getter variable might be preferred for additional flexibility.
Firebase plugins in Flutter utilize the singleton pattern extensively. For instance, signing in anonymously can be achieved with the following code:
```dart
ElevatedButton(
onPressed: () => FirebaseAuth.instance.signInAnonymously(),
child: Text('Sign in anonymously'),
)Other Firebase functionalities also rely on singletons, such as:
```dart
FirebaseFirestore.instance.doc('path/to/document');
FirebaseFunctions.instance.httpsCallable('createOrder');
FirebaseMessaging.instance.deleteToken();
```Despite their convenience, singletons have several significant drawbacks:
Singletons can make your code hard to test. Consider the following example where a singleton is used:
```dart
class FirebaseAuthRepository {
Future<void> signOut() => FirebaseAuth.instance.signOut();
}
```In this case, it’s impossible to write a test to check that `FirebaseAuth.instance.signOut()` is called. A better approach is to inject FirebaseAuth as a dependency:
```dart
class FirebaseAuthRepository {
const FirebaseAuthRepository(this._auth);
final FirebaseAuth _auth;
Future<void> signOut() => _auth.signOut();
}
```This allows for easier mocking and testing of the dependency.
Singletons can obscure dependencies within your code, making maintenance more challenging. Dependencies become much clearer when passed as explicit constructor arguments:
```dart
class FirebaseAuthRepository {
const FirebaseAuthRepository(this._auth);
final FirebaseAuth _auth;
Future<void> signOut() => _auth.signOut();
}
```Initializing certain objects can be resource-intensive. The `late` keyword in Dart allows for deferred initialization:
```dart
void main() {
late final hardWorker = HardWorker.instance;
hardWorker.logResult();
}
```However, this approach can be error-prone. Packages like `get_it` offer better control over initialization, ensuring objects are only created when first used.
Singleton instances persist for the application’s lifetime, which can lead to resource wastage if they consume significant memory or maintain open network connections. Packages like `get_it` and Riverpod provide better lifecycle management.
While Dart’s main isolate structure mitigates most thread safety concerns, using singletons in multi-threaded environments requires careful handling to avoid issues with mutable data. For heavy computations involving multiple isolates, developers must ensure that singletons do not modify shared mutable data.
Given the drawbacks associated with singletons, several alternatives can be more effective:
This design pattern involves passing dependencies as constructor arguments, promoting a clean separation of concerns. It makes classes independent of the creation of their dependencies, enhancing testability and maintainability.
```dart
class FirebaseAuthRepository {
const FirebaseAuthRepository(this._auth);
final FirebaseAuth _auth;
Future<void> signOut() => _auth.signOut();
}
```Service Locator with get_it. This package allows you to register dependencies as lazy singletons when the application starts. For instance:
```dart
void main() {
final getIt = GetIt.instance;
getIt.registerLazySingleton<FirebaseAuthRepository>(
() => FirebaseAuthRepository(FirebaseAuth.instance),
);
runApp(const MyApp());
}
```This package allows you to register dependencies as lazy singletons when the application starts. For instance:
```dart
void main() {
final getIt = GetIt.instance;
getIt.registerLazySingleton<FirebaseAuthRepository>(
() => FirebaseAuthRepository(FirebaseAuth.instance),
);
runApp(const MyApp());
}
```Accessing the dependency later is straightforward:
```dart
final authRepository = getIt.get<FirebaseAuthRepository>();
```Riverpod makes dependency management easier, especially for testing. Providers are created as global variables and accessed when needed:
```dart
final authRepositoryProvider = Provider<FirebaseAuthRepository>((ref) {
return FirebaseAuthRepository(FirebaseAuth.instance);
});
final authRepository = ref.read(authRepositoryProvider);
```Related read: Exploring Riverpod Flutter: For Optimal State Management in Flutter Applications
Singletons may seem attractive due to their simplicity and ease of use, but they introduce numerous challenges that can complicate code maintenance and testing. Alternatives such as dependency injection, `get_it`, and Riverpod offer more robust solutions for managing dependencies, resulting in cleaner, more maintainable, and testable codebases.
When developing complex Flutter applications, adopting a well-structured architecture that supports the growth of your codebase and ensures clear, manageable dependencies is crucial. You can build more robust and scalable applications by avoiding the pitfalls of singletons and leveraging effective dependency management strategies.
Happy Fluttering!!
The team at Mindbowser was highly professional, patient, and collaborative throughout our engagement. They struck the right balance between offering guidance and taking direction, which made the development process smooth. Although our project wasn’t related to healthcare, we clearly benefited...
Founder, Texas Ranch Security
Mindbowser played a crucial role in helping us bring everything together into a unified, cohesive product. Their commitment to industry-standard coding practices made an enormous difference, allowing developers to seamlessly transition in and out of the project without any confusion....
CEO, MarketsAI
I'm thrilled to be partnering with Mindbowser on our journey with TravelRite. The collaboration has been exceptional, and I’m truly grateful for the dedication and expertise the team has brought to the development process. Their commitment to our mission is...
Founder & CEO, TravelRite
The Mindbowser team's professionalism consistently impressed me. Their commitment to quality shone through in every aspect of the project. They truly went the extra mile, ensuring they understood our needs perfectly and were always willing to invest the time to...
CTO, New Day Therapeutics
I collaborated with Mindbowser for several years on a complex SaaS platform project. They took over a partially completed project and successfully transformed it into a fully functional and robust platform. Throughout the entire process, the quality of their work...
President, E.B. Carlson
Mindbowser and team are professional, talented and very responsive. They got us through a challenging situation with our IOT product successfully. They will be our go to dev team going forward.
Founder, Cascada
Amazing team to work with. Very responsive and very skilled in both front and backend engineering. Looking forward to our next project together.
Co-Founder, Emerge
The team is great to work with. Very professional, on task, and efficient.
Founder, PeriopMD
I can not express enough how pleased we are with the whole team. From the first call and meeting, they took our vision and ran with it. Communication was easy and everyone was flexible to our schedule. I’m excited to...
Founder, Seeke
We had very close go live timeline and Mindbowser team got us live a month before.
CEO, BuyNow WorldWide
If you want a team of great developers, I recommend them for the next project.
Founder, Teach Reach
Mindbowser built both iOS and Android apps for Mindworks, that have stood the test of time. 5 years later they still function quite beautifully. Their team always met their objectives and I'm very happy with the end result. Thank you!
Founder, Mindworks
Mindbowser has delivered a much better quality product than our previous tech vendors. Our product is stable and passed Well Architected Framework Review from AWS.
CEO, PurpleAnt
I am happy to share that we got USD 10k in cloud credits courtesy of our friends at Mindbowser. Thank you Pravin and Ayush, this means a lot to us.
CTO, Shortlist
Mindbowser is one of the reasons that our app is successful. These guys have been a great team.
Founder & CEO, MangoMirror
Kudos for all your hard work and diligence on the Telehealth platform project. You made it possible.
CEO, ThriveHealth
Mindbowser helped us build an awesome iOS app to bring balance to people’s lives.
CEO, SMILINGMIND
They were a very responsive team! Extremely easy to communicate and work with!
Founder & CEO, TotTech
We’ve had very little-to-no hiccups at all—it’s been a really pleasurable experience.
Co-Founder, TEAM8s
Mindbowser was very helpful with explaining the development process and started quickly on the project.
Executive Director of Product Development, Innovation Lab
The greatest benefit we got from Mindbowser is the expertise. Their team has developed apps in all different industries with all types of social proofs.
Co-Founder, Vesica
Mindbowser is professional, efficient and thorough.
Consultant, XPRIZE
Very committed, they create beautiful apps and are very benevolent. They have brilliant Ideas.
Founder, S.T.A.R.S of Wellness
Mindbowser was great; they listened to us a lot and helped us hone in on the actual idea of the app. They had put together fantastic wireframes for us.
Co-Founder, Flat Earth
Ayush was responsive and paired me with the best team member possible, to complete my complex vision and project. Could not be happier.
Founder, Child Life On Call
The team from Mindbowser stayed on task, asked the right questions, and completed the required tasks in a timely fashion! Strong work team!
CEO, SDOH2Health LLC
Mindbowser was easy to work with and hit the ground running, immediately feeling like part of our team.
CEO, Stealth Startup
Mindbowser was an excellent partner in developing my fitness app. They were patient, attentive, & understood my business needs. The end product exceeded my expectations. Thrilled to share it globally.
Owner, Phalanx
Mindbowser's expertise in tech, process & mobile development made them our choice for our app. The team was dedicated to the process & delivered high-quality features on time. They also gave valuable industry advice. Highly recommend them for app development...
Co-Founder, Fox&Fork
